All Toys: Sweet Memory & All Together
From the first toy find to the rarest Steam unlock
Scarlet Deer Inn All Toys Guide
Two Steam achievements measure childhood objects in Scarlet Deer Inn:
- Sweet Memory — Find the first toy.
- All Together — Find all the toys.
All Together is the rarest of the ten (~8–9% globally at the time of writing). This page is the method guide; exact shelf spoilers stay in chapter walkthroughs and the toys list.
Trackers: Collectible tracker, Achievement checklist. Lists: Toys, Collectibles how-to.
Spoiler warning for the video
The full no-commentary walkthrough below can reveal late rooms. Use it as a visual cleanup aid after your own story pass, not as a first-time spoiler binge.
Sweet Memory — first toy
Steam only asks you to find the first toy. That usually fires early if you:
- Help Kuba with Horace (toy horse) in the opening
- Or pick up another clearly toy-tagged object during village errands
Do not overthink the first unlock — explore shelves while walking opening village tasks. When Steam pops Sweet Memory, tick the checklist and keep hunting calmly.
All Together — every toy
All Together needs the full set. Headline finds called out across this wiki:
- Horace — story throughline from village care to escape framing
- Rag doll — major underground / childhood prop
- Shepherd’s flute — labyrinth story texture
- Remaining shelf toys and side-path interactables in village and caves
Treat early village toys as “safe bank.” After the pit, only search during search windows (lit, shortcuts open, no chase audio).
Method that actually finishes the set
- Bank village toys during errands (see Village Choices for gift achievements — separate from toys)
- Sweep Karel’s Apiary crates before the pit; remember Patch 1.008 fixed the beekeeper trap-door ladder — Updates
- Underground: solve → shortcut → light → search → log immediately in the tracker
- Finish the story via Complete Ending
- Diff tracker vs Steam; use the video only for leftover rooms
Search window rules
Search: torch up, puzzle stable, chase quiet.
Danger: creature pressure, panic staging, unfamiliar breakable floors.
Pair with torch and chase guides. Hunting during a chase is how All Together stays rare.
Hidden story achievements vs toys
No Questions, Held Breath, and Reunited are hidden on Steam. Do not confuse them with toy completion. Play the campaign; let overlay text appear. Toys are explicitly described: first toy / all toys.
Cleanup session template
- Open Steam achievements
- Open collectible tracker
- Open toys list
- Mark missing finds
- Return with shortcut memory from How to Find Shortcuts
- Stop when Steam shows All Together
Toys in Scarlet Deer Inn are parental attention made tangible. The rarest badge is just proof you kept looking after the dark closed in.
Frequently Asked Questions
Quick answers tied to this page.
Does Horace count for Sweet Memory?
Horace is a toy horse and a common early find. Confirm with the Steam unlock text on your client.
Do I need All Together to finish the story?
No. All Together is completionist. Escape and ending can proceed without a perfect toy sweep.
Why is All Together so rare?
Full toy sweeps need calm search windows across village and underground — easy to skip under chase pressure.
Where do I track toys?
Collectible tracker tool plus the toys reference list.
Should I watch the full walkthrough first?
Not for a first playthrough. Use it after credits for leftover rooms if you want visual help.
Are pie and mead achievements toy-related?
No. Those are gift choices — see Village Choices.